Kalam: Why Salafis Will Always Fail in Debates!
https://youtu.be/XUAZhPHwjD8
Intro/Context 0:00
Debate Clip 1:29
- Are attributes dependent or independent/distinct
Berhat 02:22
- Discussion on Attributes
Dr M Comment - 03:13
Explanation on St Thomas Aquinas
Descartes
Epistemology of knowledge
Necessarily existing being as starting point 6:00
- Necessary Being Acting by Free Choice or Deterministic
- Necessary being can only be one, absolute oneness
Mutakalimeen and attributes 9:55
- All is being, Separation is in our mind
- Semantic Delusion
- Mathematical Set Theory
- Nature of space/no absolute space
- Absolute nothing Vs Something
- Clarification on Sifaat/Whole Being/Essence
- Acts vs Attributes - anger/mercy
- Metaphorical Meanings/Understanding
- Allah's absolute Free Will
- Flaw in Aristotelian Logic
- Emanation/Preceding
- Flaws in Trinity
- Composition
- Only one divine being
Inability for Salafis to grasp 32:17
- Ibn Taymiyan view
- Only one Necessary being
- Developments have surpassed old views
Christians exploiting flaw in Salafi logic 35:17
- Kunfayakoon and Yadd
- Blunder of Ahmed Bin Hanbal
- Ashari
Nature of Time 43:00
- Allah and Time
- Hawkins/Quantum Fluctuation
- Penrose's view
- Time is expression of divine activity
- Ibn Taymiyyah did some break throughs
Impact of European Invasion - 51:49
Mutishabihaat/Muhkam
Divine Foreknowledge/Jabbar
Misunderstanding of time 54:30
- Hawkin's mistake re: 4 Dimensional space, and flipping to make time
- Choice of possible universes, hikma, free will
Ashari, Jabari, Mutazila 1:07:05
- Allahs Hikma, misapplication of Good
- Logical contradiction of judging God's judgement
Nicea and adoption of blasphemous trinity 1:17:45
Thunn and speculation 1:18:30
- Avoid things, other than what is disctated by rational necessity and sanctioned by Quran
Perfect being and meaning of good 1:20:25
- Haqq
- Irrational
- Contingent being
Summary so far 1:24:25
- Symbolism
- Metaphorical Expressions, ibn Abbas
- Problem saying those who believe different are deviant 1:29:50
- Qadr and possibilities and realisation in light of Quran
Purpose of texts to understand metaphysical 1:31:45
Flaw in Christian narrative re: decision
Qurtubi
Possible Future episode 1:33:45
Fatalism
https://youtu.be/XUAZhPHwjD8
Intro/Context 0:00
Debate Clip 1:29
- Are attributes dependent or independent/distinct
Berhat 02:22
- Discussion on Attributes
Dr M Comment - 03:13
Explanation on St Thomas Aquinas
Descartes
Epistemology of knowledge
Necessarily existing being as starting point 6:00
- Necessary Being Acting by Free Choice or Deterministic
- Necessary being can only be one, absolute oneness
Mutakalimeen and attributes 9:55
- All is being, Separation is in our mind
- Semantic Delusion
- Mathematical Set Theory
- Nature of space/no absolute space
- Absolute nothing Vs Something
- Clarification on Sifaat/Whole Being/Essence
- Acts vs Attributes - anger/mercy
- Metaphorical Meanings/Understanding
- Allah's absolute Free Will
- Flaw in Aristotelian Logic
- Emanation/Preceding
- Flaws in Trinity
- Composition
- Only one divine being
Inability for Salafis to grasp 32:17
- Ibn Taymiyan view
- Only one Necessary being
- Developments have surpassed old views
Christians exploiting flaw in Salafi logic 35:17
- Kunfayakoon and Yadd
- Blunder of Ahmed Bin Hanbal
- Ashari
Nature of Time 43:00
- Allah and Time
- Hawkins/Quantum Fluctuation
- Penrose's view
- Time is expression of divine activity
- Ibn Taymiyyah did some break throughs
Impact of European Invasion - 51:49
Mutishabihaat/Muhkam
Divine Foreknowledge/Jabbar
Misunderstanding of time 54:30
- Hawkin's mistake re: 4 Dimensional space, and flipping to make time
- Choice of possible universes, hikma, free will
Ashari, Jabari, Mutazila 1:07:05
- Allahs Hikma, misapplication of Good
- Logical contradiction of judging God's judgement
Nicea and adoption of blasphemous trinity 1:17:45
Thunn and speculation 1:18:30
- Avoid things, other than what is disctated by rational necessity and sanctioned by Quran
Perfect being and meaning of good 1:20:25
- Haqq
- Irrational
- Contingent being
Summary so far 1:24:25
- Symbolism
- Metaphorical Expressions, ibn Abbas
- Problem saying those who believe different are deviant 1:29:50
- Qadr and possibilities and realisation in light of Quran
Purpose of texts to understand metaphysical 1:31:45
Flaw in Christian narrative re: decision
Qurtubi
Possible Future episode 1:33:45
Fatalism
تعليقات
إرسال تعليق